1900 2039 (ext: 555)
TS. Vũ Xuân Hướng
ABSTRACT
With advancements in Artificial Intelligence (AI) and machine learning, education systems are transforming. This paper analyzes the challenges AI poses for schools and teachers and the opportunities it presents for personalized learning. It evaluates three central challenges: updating curriculums with AI disciplines, adopting adaptive teaching techniques, and developing evaluation metrics for new paradigms. Policymakers must incorporate data science and machine learning into core frameworks. Self-paced learning platforms require new classroom dynamics. Assessments must prioritize higher-order thinking. The article emphasizes three crucial opportunities within an AI-driven education framework – broadening access, strengthening educators, and tailoring education. Online learning currently extends admission beyond geographical and economic hurdles. Intelligent content provision enables personalization for learners with disabilities. AI liberates precious teaching hours from routine tasks to concentrate on student welfare. Moreover, evolving learning technologies persistently amend lesson designs based on immediate responses. However, to actualize this vision, we need to tackle ethical concerns like the privacy of student data and the inherent biases that could infiltrate algorithms. In conclusion, despite some inevitable hitches in current systems, AI brings forth hopeful remedies to persistent issues such as inclusivity, resource limitations, and personalized guidance on a large scale. The article highlights that policy, institutional readiness, and public consciousness are equally important in steering this transformation. Educators need to acknowledge the potential of AI, prompting culture modifications centered around new perceptions of educational quality, accomplishment, and preparedness for the workforce. Further national initiatives merging education and AI will set the course for the future.
Keywords: Artificial Intelligence in Education, Adaptive Teaching Techniques, Personalized Learning Platforms, Ethical Concerns in AI Education, Inclusive Education with AI, Policy for AI Integration in Education
INTRODUCTION
The rapid advancement of AI is leading to significant changes in various industries, such as transportation, finance, and healthcare (Soni, 2022). However, one area that stands to undergo a major transformation with the emergence of AI is education. By combining cutting-edge educational technologies with extensive data sets, machine learning processes, and intelligent tutoring systems, there is potential for a complete redefinition of learning methods and curriculum selection. Additionally, these advancements have the ability to personalize teaching approaches and improve accessibility for students from diverse backgrounds or geographical locations (Magidin de Kramer et al., 2020; Mellor et al., 2022). Therefore it is crucial to examine how AI will continue to impact and reshape the field of education. This examination should focus on two key aspects: identifying obstacles that need to be overcome and exploring the possibilities that can be harnessed.
The increasing impact AI in our society and its potential for future careers requires a rapid overhaul of educational curriculums. This is necessary to align them with highly sought-after skills such as data science and machine learning. At the same time, there are new societal issues to contend with, such as responsibility and bias in algorithms (Doyle et al., 2021). Additionally, the rise of online educational resources demands a significant transformation in learning strategies that prioritize personalized, self-directed experiences. However, as these innovative tools and platforms emerge, policymakers face a dilemma in determining their role and effectiveness. This is especially true for those accustomed to traditional standardized testing as a measure of proficiency (Tang et al., 2021). Despite numerous challenges, there are also exciting opportunities to improve access to education, empower educators, and customize instruction like never before through the use of AI capabilities.
Recent findings suggest a profound understanding of the potential impact data-driven insights can have on individual student’s learning trajectory and progression. It elucidates how instructors can employ targeted interventions in a timely manner, simultaneously allowing for more time to be dedicated to crucial mentorship tasks (Henning et al., 2022; Parson et al., 2022). Advances in intelligent tutoring systems have been shown to effectively identify areas of deficiency in knowledge and adjust according to the disparate pace, interests, and strengths of students (Kartal et al., 2022). The advent of online education via digital learning platforms has allowed for the transcendence of geographical and economic barriers that previously restricted access to a significant population of aspiring students across the globe (Chen et al., 2021). It is evident that the effective utilization of AI bears considerable prospects for democratizing education and providing continuous, personalized learning guidance on a large scale. Nonetheless, these advancements also prompt critical questions regarding practicality, ethical usage, and the evolving relationship between human educators and AI technologies. The conversation needs to be steered towards ensuring that AI is used responsibly and that its interaction with human teachers results in a balanced and effective learning environment.
The objective of this study is to conduct a thorough assessment of the complex issues that are shifting educational models, while also identifying potential avenues for innovative learning and accessibility in an environment that increasingly incorporates AI. This involves the modification of curriculum structures, the restructure of classroom interactions, the evaluation of learning results, and the management of ethical AI – the research will delve into critical topics that necessitate immediate policy interventions. By looking at ongoing experiments that incorporate AI, it will outline the key tasks and necessities for different parties involved as society accepts this technological metamorphosis in education systems on a broad scale.
CHALLENGES FOR EDUCATION IN AI ERA
Keeping Curriculums Updated With AI-Related Concepts
Education systems worldwide are currently facing a significant challenge in keeping their school curriculums up-to-date and relevant in light of the rapid advancements in AI capabilities and their wide-ranging applications across various fields (Mohanty & Parida, 2022; Vinuesa et al., 2022). As disciplines such as data science, machine learning, and AI ethics continue to gain prominence, it has become increasingly essential for students to acquire knowledge and skills in these areas in order to thrive in the future job market across industries such as computer science, healthcare, finance, law, and policy formulation (Gkotsis & Stepanyan, 2022). However, incorporating new AI themes into the existing curriculum structures poses two primary obstacles that education systems must overcome (Lockery & Gutteridge, 2022). Firstly, there is the challenge of identifying the most relevant and impactful AI topics to include in the curriculum. With the rapid pace of AI advancements, it can be difficult to determine which areas will have the greatest impact on future industries and job roles. Education systems need to carefully evaluate the potential long-term significance of different AI themes and prioritize those that are most likely to shape the future landscape. Secondly, there is the issue of integrating these new AI themes into the existing curriculum without sacrificing the core fundamentals and essential knowledge that students need to acquire. While it is important to introduce AI-related subjects, it is equally crucial to ensure that students have a solid foundation in traditional subjects such as mathematics, science, and language arts. Striking the right balance between incorporating new AI themes and maintaining a well-rounded education is a complex task that requires careful planning and collaboration among educators, policymakers, and industry experts.
To address these challenges, education systems need to adopt a flexible and adaptive approach to curriculum development. This involves regularly reviewing and updating the curriculum to reflect the latest advancements in AI and their implications for various industries. It also requires fostering partnerships and collaborations between educational institutions and industry leaders to ensure that the curriculum aligns with the needs and demands of the job market. In conclusion, the rapid advancement of AI capabilities and their widespread applications across various fields present a significant challenge for education systems worldwide. However, by carefully identifying and integrating relevant AI themes into the curriculum while maintaining a strong foundation in traditional subjects, education systems can equip students with the necessary knowledge and skills to excel in the future job market. Adopting a flexible and adaptive approach to curriculum development is crucial in keeping pace with the ever-evolving AI landscape and ensuring that students are prepared for the challenges and opportunities that lie ahead.
In the first place, policy managers who have been accustomed to following a more fixed and sequential curriculum mapping approach for many years now find themselves in a position where they need to embrace more adaptable models that are updated on an annual basis, or even more frequently, such as semester-wise. This shift in approach is necessary to keep up with the rapidly evolving landscape of education and the advancements in technology. Secondly, there are numerous uncertainties surrounding the most effective ways to incorporate Artificial Intelligence (AI) throughout K-12 and tertiary education. Should AI be introduced as standalone courses, integrated through multidisciplinary methods, or ingrained within traditional computer science classes? This question poses a significant challenge for educators and policymakers alike. Finding the right balance between maintaining consistency in teaching standards and promptly integrating AI concepts is an intricate juggling act. On one hand, there is a need for stability in teaching methodologies to ensure that students receive a comprehensive and well-rounded education. On the other hand, there is a pressing need to adapt and assimilate AI ideas into the curriculum to prepare students for the future job market and equip them with the necessary skills. The integration of AI into education requires careful consideration and planning. Educators must navigate the complexities of incorporating AI in a way that enhances learning outcomes and promotes critical thinking skills. This involves exploring innovative teaching methods, leveraging AI tools and resources, and fostering collaboration among educators, researchers, and industry professionals.
Furthermore, policy managers must stay informed about the latest developments in AI and education to make informed decisions and create policies that support the effective integration of AI in schools and universities. This includes staying updated on research findings, attending conferences and workshops, and collaborating with experts in the field. In conclusion, the adoption of adaptable curriculum mapping models and the integration of AI in education present both challenges and opportunities for policy managers and educators. Striking a balance between maintaining teaching standards and embracing AI concepts requires careful planning, collaboration, and a commitment to providing students with a well-rounded education that prepares them for the future.
Rethinking Teaching Approaches and Learning Designs
The integration of AI-powered educational technologies, such as intelligent tutoring systems and virtual simulations, has necessitated a reevaluation of traditional teaching methods in both physical classrooms and online learning environments (Holmes et al., 2022). These innovative tools have greatly expanded the possibilities for self-directed learning among students. However, there is concern that if the role of human educators is not fully reconsidered, these technologies may inadvertently perpetuate passive learning dynamics (Jiang et al., 2021). According to constructivist theories of learning, simply delivering content is insufficient for fostering meaningful skill development. Students also need opportunities for analytical discussions, critical assessments, creative expressions, and hands-on experiences—all actively guided by instructors (Wass & Golding 2014). Therefore, it is crucial to engage in policy discussions that prioritize updating pedagogical standards to leverage AI as an enhancer of human teaching rather than a substitute for nuanced instruction (Luckin et al., 2016).
In light of these developments, teacher training programs must adapt to equip the next generation of educators with the necessary technical and socioemotional competencies to navigate this evolving educational landscape. It is no longer sufficient for teachers to solely possess subject matter expertise; they must also be proficient in leveraging AI-enabled tools and understanding how to effectively integrate them into their teaching practices. Additionally, teachers need to develop strong interpersonal skills to foster meaningful connections with their students and create a supportive learning environment. In conclusion, the rise of AI-enabled educational technologies has revolutionized the field of education. While these tools offer tremendous potential for enhancing self-directed learning, it is essential to ensure that they are used in a way that complements and amplifies the role of human educators. By reimagining traditional teaching methods and equipping teachers with the necessary skills, we can create a harmonious blend of technology and human instruction that maximizes student learning outcomes.
Assessing Effectiveness
When it comes to assessing the effectiveness of AI technologies, governments face unprecedented obstacles, particularly those accustomed to standardized testing methods (von Davier & Khorramdel, 2022). With the growing prevalence of adaptive learning platforms focused on competency acquisition, policymakers find themselves in need of new standards that go beyond measuring factual recall or speed and instead concentrate on evaluating mastery, knowledge application, and higher-order skills (Molina et al., 2022). Additionally, as algorithms become more integrated into learning processes, it becomes crucial to include criteria such as ethical reasoning and bias assessments in progress dashboards (Gkotsis & Stepanyan, 2022). This revamp of assessment methodologies is essential for guiding the appropriate implementation of AI that is suitable for local contexts (Timms, 2016). In fact, global cooperation around the development and implementation of appropriate evaluation principles could potentially provide a pathway for countries that are grappling with the transformation of outdated education norms. Therefore, it is clear that the evaluation of AI technologies in the educational context is a complex and multifaceted task that requires careful consideration and collaboration among various stakeholders.
OPPORTUNITIES WITH AI-DRIVEN EDUCATION
Expanding Access and Equity
AI-integrated educational technologies are bringing about a revolution in the field of education by demonstrating tremendous potential for increasing access to learning opportunities for marginalized communities. These communities often encounter various obstacles such as cost, location, infrastructure, disabilities, and social biases. Scholars like Devedžić et al. (2021) and Vinuesa et al. (2022) have emphasized the transformative impact of AI in this context. One significant way in which AI is enhancing accessibility to education is through the availability of massive open online courses and digital content. These resources are now accessible either free or at affordable prices, ensuring that students from economically disadvantaged backgrounds can access high-quality curricula (Chen et al., 2021). This equalization of education is a game-changer for individuals who previously faced limited opportunities due to financial constraints. Moreover, AI-powered adaptive learning systems are dismantling barriers for people with visual impairments or other disabilities. Technologies like text-to-speech enable these individuals to actively engage in educational activities (Nandigam et al., 2022). By providing inclusive tools that cater to diverse needs within the classroom setting, AI promotes greater participation and engagement among learners.
By customizing the pace and difficulty levels automatically, AI removes the stigma associated with needing additional support. This not only enhances the learning experience for individuals with disabilities but also promotes inclusivity in the education system. However, it is important to acknowledge that there are still challenges to overcome in order to fully democratize access to AI-integrated education technologies. One such challenge is the digital divide caused by uneven internet connectivity and limited device access. While AI has the potential to bridge the gap, efforts from multiple stakeholders are required to address these issues (Timms, 2022). Collaborative initiatives involving governments, educational institutions, and technology companies can play a crucial role in ensuring that all individuals, regardless of their socio-economic background or geographical location, can benefit from AI in education. In conclusion, AI-integrated education technologies have the power to transform the educational landscape by making learning opportunities more accessible to marginalized communities. Through initiatives like mass open online courses, digitized content, and adaptive learning systems, AI is breaking down barriers and expanding inclusion in education. However, it is essential to address challenges such as the digital divide to ensure that the benefits of AI in education reach everyone.
Teacher Empowerment Through AI Assistance
Utilizing AI technology, educators in the field of education have found AI-based analytics on individual progress to be a valuable resource. This tool allows instructors to shift their focus from basic content delivery to higher-level teaching tasks. These tasks include facilitating group discussions, providing guidance for open-ended projects, and nurturing critical thinking skills. As a result, the learning environment becomes more interactive and dynamic as instructors engage with students on a deeper level. Additionally, the automation of administrative tasks through AI systems has proven to be beneficial for educators. By relieving instructors of mundane administrative duties, they can allocate more time and energy towards directly interacting with students. This is especially advantageous for students who require socioemotional support or career mentoring as it enables instructors to provide personalized attention based on their individual needs. Overall, AI-based analytics not only enhance the teaching experience but also save time for educators by streamlining administrative processes. With this technology at their disposal, instructors are able to create a more engaging learning environment while providing tailored support for each student’s growth and development.
However, in spite of the numerous benefits that AI brings to the field of education, such as increased efficiency, personalized learning experiences, and data-driven insights, there still exist cultural barriers and concerns regarding the potential displacement of human instructors by machines. This hesitance to fully embrace AI technology presents significant obstacles to its widespread adoption and implementation in educational settings. It is essential for policy makers and educational leaders to address these anxieties and reinforce the notion that AI is not intended to replace human instructors, but rather augment the quality of education. By leveraging AI technology, educators have the opportunity to create an engaging and personalized learning environment that caters to the unique needs of each student. This collaboration between AI and human instructors can result in a more efficient and effective learning experience for students, as it allows for the automation of repetitive tasks and the provision of valuable insights based on data analysis. Furthermore, the integration of AI in education can lead to improved overall educational quality. With AI’s ability to analyze vast amounts of data, educators can gain valuable insights into student performance, learning patterns, and areas of improvement. This data-driven approach enables instructors to tailor their teaching methods and interventions to meet the specific needs of each student, ultimately enhancing their learning outcomes.
Moreover, AI can assist in the creation of adaptive learning platforms that adjust the pace and content of instruction based on individual student progress. This personalized approach ensures that students receive the appropriate level of challenge and support, maximizing their learning potential. Additionally, AI-powered virtual tutors and chatbots can provide immediate feedback and assistance to students, promoting independent learning and self-reflection. In conclusion, AI has the capacity to enhance human teaching by automating repetitive tasks, providing valuable insights, and facilitating personalized learning experiences. By embracing AI technology and leveraging its capabilities, educators have the opportunity to create an engaging and dynamic learning environment that fosters student success. It is crucial for educational institutions to address the cultural barriers and concerns surrounding AI, emphasizing its role as a tool to augment, rather than replace, human instructors. Through this collaborative approach, AI and human instructors can work together to improve overall educational quality and ensure that students receive the best possible learning experience.
Customizable, Student-Centric Learning
In contrast to traditional curriculums that follow a one-size-fits-all approach, artificial intelligence (AI) enables personalized recommendations and adaptable learning pace based on individual strengths and interests (Kartal et al., 2022). This customized method of education provides students with a tailored learning experience, ensuring their engagement and motivation. Through AI, continuous assessment becomes feasible, allowing educators to adjust difficulty levels, introduce new concepts based on mastery of prerequisites, and modify teaching strategies if desired outcomes are not achieved (Mellor et al., 2022). By integrating AI into education, students gain more control over their knowledge progression. The passive absorption of uniform instructions is replaced by an empowered approach where learners take charge of their own learning journey. This shift in dynamics promotes autonomy and independence as students are encouraged to explore subjects they find interesting and delve deeper into areas where they excel.
Although it is undeniable that AI brings numerous benefits to the field of education, it is crucial to consider the ethical implications of handling extensive personalized data. With the rise of AI systems, there is an unprecedented ability to gather and analyze large amounts of information about individual learners. This, however, raises significant concerns regarding privacy. The question of how to effectively manage this data in an ethical and responsible manner on a large scale is a complex challenge that needs to be addressed (Gkotsis & Stepanyan, 2022). Despite these concerns, there are reasons for optimism. Frameworks are being developed to address the responsible usage of data in AI systems, offering promising solutions for this issue. These frameworks aim to strike a balance between the benefits of personalized learning and the need to protect students’ privacy. By implementing these frameworks, educational institutions can ensure that AI is used in a way that respects ethical standards and safeguards the privacy of learners. In conclusion, the incorporation of AI into education presents a transformative approach to learning. It offers personalized recommendations, adaptable pacing, and increased student autonomy. These advantages have the potential to revolutionize teaching and learning methods. However, it is important to address privacy concerns and ensure that AI is used responsibly. By doing so, we can fully harness the potential of AI in education while safeguarding the privacy and rights of learners.
KEY INITIATIVES AND EXPERIMENTS UNDERWAY
Several promising experiments at the intersection of education and AI are currently underway across various countries that underscore the transformative potential of these emerging technologies. These initiatives aim to harness the power of artificial intelligence to enhance the learning experience and improve educational outcomes for students.
One notable example of such experimentation is the development of an intelligent tutoring application called Deep Tutor. This innovative tool utilizes conversational agents to deliver personalized instruction in complex concepts of physics. By tailoring the content to each student’s specific line of questioning, Deep Tutor ensures that the learning experience is highly individualized and engaging. Furthermore, the application continually refines its explanations based on the student’s reactions, allowing for a dynamic and adaptive learning process. Early results from the implementation of Deep Tutor have been highly encouraging. Students who have been trained by the AI tutor have shown a significant improvement in their ability to solve problems accurately, with over a 50% increase compared to traditional teaching methods. This demonstrates the potential of AI in revolutionizing the way we educate and empower students to excel in their academic pursuits. Singapore, known for its forward-thinking approach to education, is at the forefront of pioneering a national AI strategy in the field of education. The country is actively developing a core curriculum for AI skills, recognizing the importance of equipping students with the knowledge and competencies required to thrive in the digital age.
Additionally, Singapore is expanding access to cutting-edge subjects related to AI through subsidized courses, ensuring that students from all backgrounds have the opportunity to engage with these transformative technologies. This holistic integration of AI in both instruction frameworks and delivery platforms is crucial for the successful execution of AI in education. By incorporating AI into the core curriculum and providing widespread access to AI-related subjects, Singapore is setting an example for other countries to follow. The aim is to create an educational ecosystem that embraces the potential of AI to enhance teaching and learning, preparing students for the challenges and opportunities of the future. In conclusion, the ongoing experiments at the intersection of education and AI hold great promise for revolutionizing the way we teach and learn. The example of Deep Tutor showcases the potential of AI in delivering personalized instruction and improving student outcomes. Singapore’s national AI strategy in education further highlights the importance of integrating AI into the core curriculum and expanding access to AI-related subjects. These initiatives underscore the transformative potential of AI in education and pave the way for a future where technology plays a central role in empowering students and educators alike.
The Abu Dhabi Department of Education and Knowledge has taken a proactive approach to preparing high school students for the future by implementing a specialized program called AI Camp. This program focuses on imparting coding and data science foundations to students through immersive workshops. The success of AI Camp has been so significant that plans are already underway to expand it across the Middle East (Gkotsis & Stepanyan, 2022). By providing students with the necessary skills and knowledge in artificial intelligence, the program aims to equip them with the tools they need to thrive in a rapidly evolving technological landscape. In addition to AI Camp, there has been a surge in the development and implementation of adaptive learning apps that leverage AI technology to provide personalized math and reading guidance to students in India and Africa. These apps, created by private players in the education sector, have shown promising results in improving conceptual clarity and confidence among students who previously lacked formal access to education (Mellor et al., 2022). This demonstrates the potential of edtech innovations in breaking down barriers to entry and ensuring that all students have equal opportunities to learn and succeed.
These experiments and initiatives highlight the vast horizons and tremendous potential that arise when education systems purposefully leverage AI capabilities. However, mainstreaming these efforts requires coordinated policies and public-private partnerships. By working together, governments, educational institutions, and private organizations can create an ecosystem that fosters the integration of AI in education. The rewards of such collaboration can be transformative, not only in terms of improved learning outcomes but also in terms of increased access to quality education for all students. In conclusion, the Abu Dhabi Department of Education and Knowledge’s AI Camp and the development of adaptive learning apps leveraging AI technology are just two examples of how education systems are embracing the potential of AI. These initiatives not only prepare students for the future but also address the educational inequalities that exist in many regions. By harnessing the power of AI, education can become more inclusive and equitable, ensuring that every student has the opportunity to thrive and succeed.
CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE OUTLOOK
In conclusion, this research paper has conducted an in-depth examination of the evolving realm of artificial intelligence within the educational sector – pinpointing both critical issues requiring immediate solutions, and potential prospects that can be capitalized upon to improve accessibility, inclusivity, and educational results. The scrutiny demonstrates that while AI ushers in inevitable teething troubles, policy makers and institutions that strategically adopt this metamorphosis stand a chance to resolve some of the deeply rooted problems in large-scale educational systems. For instance, continuous bespoke guidance was something that was simply unthinkable in conventional models. Likewise, extending quality education to underprivileged communities grappling with socioeconomic obstacles seemed like an insurmountable task in the past. AI’s current abilities make it possible to find solutions, as long as ethical usage and balanced supervision are given top priority.
The article highlights the indispensable elements such as revised data management frameworks, re-envisioned educational norms and collaborations, progressive evaluation techniques, and continuous funding for ethical AI integration. These must be in place to prevent the significant potential from becoming harmful. The challenges of promoting prejudice, violating privacy, amplifying social isolation, and an absence of responsibility still pose a significant threat if our focus diverges. In essence, the communication advocates for careful yet purposeful positivity. The introduction of AI in the field of education signifies an unstoppable wave of change. As indicated by emerging trials and government efforts globally, policy cycles are already acknowledging this impending reality, aiming to capitalize on this movement from the onset. Now, the pressing needs are to enable stakeholders across academia, technology, ethics, and society to play a proactive role in defining the parameters of this exciting upheaval as it develops – ensuring that principles of quality, access, and respect remain central while redefining education’s foundations in the forthcoming epoch of artificial intelligence.
REFERENCES
Chen, J. C., Dobinson, T., & Kent, S. (2021). Lecturers’ perceptions and experiences of blackboard collaborate as a distance learning and teaching tool via open universities Australia (OUA). Open Learning: The Journal of Open, Distance and e-Learning, 36(3), 231–247.
Devedžić, V., Jovanović, J., Delić, V., Ševarac, Z., & Medenica, M. (2021). A framework for evaluating AIEd solutions’ pedagogical, ethical and privacy aspects. Education Sciences, 11(12), 840.
Doyle, O., Han, J., Logan, J. R., Qatar Computing Research Institute, HBKU Qatar Foundation, Doha, Qatar, Schwarz, C. V., The University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway, & Mulfinger, L. (2021). The robot revolution will not be automated: Preparing students for the future of work through human-robot teaming. Information and Learning Sciences, 122(5/6), 305-315.
Gkotsis, G., & Stepanyan, K. (2022). Education in the era of artificial intelligence: Ethics and governance. Education Sciences, 12(1), 18.
Henning, P. B., Nielsen, M. V., Henning, A., Schulz-Henning, J., Pahlke, E., Schwarzer, D., & Zeller, N. (2022). Machine learning predicts individual students’ learning needs and helps to identify efficient support strategies that teachers can provide. Nature Partner Journals Science of Learning, 7(1).
Holmes, W., Bialik, M., & Fadel, C. (2022). Artificial intelligence in education: Promises and implications for teaching and learning. Center for Curriculum Redesign.
Jiang, F., Pollock, J. L., & Duraiappah, A. K. (2021). Reinforcement learning systems for education: Opportunities for supporting diversity and inclusion. Preprint – SocArXiv.
Kartal, G., Cheng, Z., & Aslan, S. (2022). Personalization in intelligent tutoring systems: A systematic mapping study. The Asia – Pacific Education Researcher, 1-13.
Lockery, M., & Gutteridge, N. (2022). Artificial Intelligence and the prospects for education: Can AI make personalized, self-paced learning a reality? Journal of Educational Technology & Society, 25(1), 11-26.
Luckin, R., Holmes, W., Griffiths, M., & Forcier, L. B. (2016). Intelligence Unleashed: An argument for AI in Education. Pearson.
Magidin de Kramer, R., O’Dwyer, L. M., Masters, J., Dash, S., & Russell, M. (2020). Relationship between teacher professional development and changes in student English language proficiency outcomes. Regional Educational Laboratory Northeast & Islands.
Mellor, A., Bouchelle, Z., & Lobene, E. (2022). An artificial intelligence model to personalize early math instruction. Educational Technology Research and Development, 1-24.
Mohanty, S., & Parida, A. K. (2022). Intelligent learning using artificial intelligence: Applications, challenges and adaptation. Education and Information Technologies.
Molina, A. I., Patarroyo-Angarita, J. A., & Ramírez, C. C. (2022). Applications of artificial intelligence for language learning assessment: An integrative review. Computer Assisted Language Learning, 1-42.
Nandigam, D., Tavva, V., & Reddy, N. V. S. (2022). Applications of artificial intelligence in education for visually impaired people: a review. Assistive Technology, 1-11.
Parson, V., Reddy, V., Wood, J., & Senior, C. (2022). Do interactive apps promote learning? A meta-analysis with recommendations for developers. Educational Research Review, 100432.
Rus, V., D’Mello, S., Hu, X., & Graesser, A. C. (2022). Multimodal Learning Analytics to Study Learning with Advanced Technologies. In Multimodal Learning Analytics. Academic Press.
Soni, N. (2022). Enterprise AI adoption trends 2022. Retrieved February 16, 2022, from https://www.datamation.com/artificial-intelligence/enterprise-ai-adoption/
Tang, X., Yin, Y., & Min, L. (2021). Big data and artificial intelligence models for education. Journal of Management Analytics, 8(4), 399-417.
Timms, M. J. (2016). Letting artificial intelligence in education out of the box: Educational cobots and smart classrooms. International Journal of Artificial Intelligence in Education, 26(2), 701-712.
Timms, M. J. (2022). Human–AI collaboration for personalised education. International Journal of Information and Learning Technology.
Tuomi, I. (2022). The impact of AI on learning, teaching, and education: Policies for the future. Routledge.
Vinuesa, R., Azizpour, H., Leite, I., Olsson, C., Boeva, V., Smith, D. M., Jamone, L., Lourenco, A., Edsinger, A., Edsinger, E., … & Brachmond, F. (2022). The role of artificial intelligence in achieving the Sustainable Development Goals. Nature communications, 13(1), 1-13.
Von Davier, A. A., & Khorramdel, L. (2022). Harnessing the power of data science and artificial intelligence for learning and assessment: Modern psychometrics and the path forward. Applied Measurement in Education, 1-21.
Wass, R., & Golding, C. (2014). Sharpening a tool for teaching: the zone of proximal development. Teaching in Higher Education, 19(6), 671-684.
Zhong, B., Wang, Q., Chen, J., & Li, Y. (2022). Global research trends in AI education: A bibliometric and visualized analysis. Journal of Computing in Higher Education, 34(1), 439-466.
